Skip to content
L'Officiel Lifestyle
Lifestyle

More Than 2 Weekly Servings of These Foods Could Raise Breast Cancer Risk by 28%, Scientists Say

But there are a few critical caveats.

by Kevin Harson

More Than 2 Weekly Servings of These Foods Could Raise Breast Cancer Risk by 28%, Scientists Say
  • A new study finds that women who ate more than two servings of certain sugary foods per week had an increased risk of breast cancer.
  • There was no association with amount of fruit consumption or total sugar intake.
  • Experts explain a few important caveats to keep in mind when interpreting the findings.

Breast cancer is the most common cancer in American women aside from skin cancers, according to the American Cancer Society. In fact, it accounts for about one in three new cancers in women each year. So it’s not surprising that thinking about breast cancer risk is something that factors into many of our day-to-day lives.

Of course, a variety of factors play a part in each person’s individual risk—including family history, environment, lifestyle behaviors, and others. Then, of course, there’s diet, which plays a role in the development of many types of cancers, including that of the breast.

Meet the Experts: Katie McLean, M.S.H., R.D.N., L.D.N., senior oncology dietitian at Houston Methodist Sugar Land Cancer Center; Tiffany Troso-Sandoval, M.D., board-certified medical oncologist and founder of Second Look Oncology.

Now, a new study is digging into diet a little deeper, specifically looking at how sugar consumption may affect breast cancer risk. Below, an oncologist and dietitian weigh in on the findings, and explain whether or not you should be worried about the extra teaspoon of sweetener in your morning coffee.

What did the study find?

In the study, which was published in the European Journal of Nutrition, researchers followed over 71,000 Korean women for about nine years and tracked how often they ate seven categories of sugary foods: sugary cereals, jam and butter, cakes and cookies, ice cream, sweets, carbonated drinks, and sweetened tea. Then, they tracked how many participants were diagnosed with breast cancer by the end of the study.

After crunching the numbers, the researchers discovered that women who ate those sugary foods more than twice a week had about a 28% higher risk of developing breast cancer than those who ate them less than once a month.

“Interestingly, only sugary cereal and ice cream contributed significantly to the risk,” explains Katie McLean, M.S.H., R.D.N., L.D.N., senior oncology dietitian at Houston Methodist Sugar Land Cancer Center. “Cakes, cookies, candy, and soda did not raise the risk on their own.”

What’s more, the researchers also found that fruit—which, of course, contains natural sugars—was the largest contributor to the participants’ overall sugar intake, making up almost half of it. But the amount of fruit consumption didn’t show any link to breast cancer risk. There also was no association between total sugar intake and breast cancer risk.

“So I would not tell women this study proves sugar causes breast cancer,” adds Tiffany Troso-Sandoval, M.D., board-certified medical oncologist and founder of Second Look Oncology. “Rather, it suggests that the type of food matters more than the grams of sugar on the label.”

How sugar may affect breast cancer risk

“Many women worry that sugar feeds cancer directly. That is not actually how it works,” explains Dr. Troso-Sandoval. “The mechanism is much more complicated.”

Google

Add Prevention as a preferred source in your Google search results.

Use your Google account to add this to your settings.

Hormones and insulin spikes likely play a part, she adds. “When you eat a lot of refined, sugary food, your body can become resistant to insulin. Your insulin goes up, along with a related hormone called IGF-1, and both can push breast cells to grow,” she continues. Because both hormones can encourage cells to multiply, this may help set the stage for breast cancer development. Other research has tied sweets and sugary drinks to denser breast tissue, which has been linked to greater breast cancer risk, too, she adds.

There’s also the fact that not all sources of sugar are created equal. “When we eat whole fruit, we’re consuming so much more than just sugar. Our bodies are getting fiber, vitamins, minerals, and beneficial plant compounds called phytonutrients,” says McLean. “The fiber in fruit helps slow digestion, keeps us feeling full, and helps regulate blood sugar. Fruit also contains antioxidants and other phytonutrients that may help reduce inflammation in our bodies and support overall health.” These benefits may help explain why fruit, which contains natural sources of sugar, wasn’t linked to an increase in breast cancer risk, even though it accounted for a significant amount of overall total sugar intake.

“I believe this is an important reminder that we need to look at the whole food and its overall nutritional value rather than labeling a food ‘good’ or ‘bad’ based solely on its sugar content,” says McLean.

And it’s also possible that the group who ate more added sugar could simply have a diet pattern in general that’s not as nutritious as the women who ate less added sugar—the study wasn’t able to tease out the element of overall diet quality. And the foods the participants ate that were high in sugar also likely included other components that are less healthy, which could account for some of the relationship, too. For instance, foods that are high in added sugars, like those study participants ate, are often also highly processed, low in fiber, and less nutrient-dense than whole foods, McLean explains. That falls in line with separate research that links highly processed foods to an increased likelihood of certain cancers.

Another important note: Our experts add that these findings may not be as applicable to the American population due to the differences between American and Korean eating habits. “I would not assume the 28% carries over to American women,” says Dr. Troso-Sandoval. “These women in the study ate very differently than most Americans. Almost half their sugar came from fruit, and the top sugar source among their sweets was traditional sweetened tea, not soda or baked goods,” which is different from how Americans get their sugar. What’s more, she adds, the link between added sugar and breast cancer showed up mainly in women under 50, and in the U.S., most breast cancers are diagnosed after that age.

McLean agrees, and adds that we need additional research in other populations before determining whether the results apply more generally to all women.

The bottom line

“Don’t be afraid of fruit,” says Dr. Troso-Sandoval. “The foods worth cutting back on are the processed sweets that give you sugar and very little nutrition … so make a sensible change.”

Added sugar can show up in sources you won’t expect, like granola bars, coffee drinks, condiments, salad dressings, cereals, and flavored oatmeal, says McLean, so it’s worth giving the nutrition label a quick glance if you’re not sure what’s in them. “Individually, they may not provide a significant source of sugar, but cumulatively, they can certainly add up,” she says.

Still, says Dr. Troso-Sandoval, “do not panic over a bowl of ice cream.” And don’t forget about the evidence-backed lifestyle behaviors that have been shown to reduce your risk. On that note, she recommends moderating your alcohol consumption, exercising regularly, maintaining a healthy weight (especially after menopause), and knowing your family’s medical history.

“Ask whether genetic testing makes sense for you, and know when you should be screened. Diet is only one piece,” she adds. “The women I worry about most are the ones counting sugar grams who have never talked to their doctor about their family history or have not had genetic testing when indicated.”

When it comes to dessert, if you do want to make changes toward more whole foods, there are a few substitutions that McLean recommends: plain Greek yogurt with berries and a drizzle of honey instead of flavored yogurt, adding cinnamon and milk to coffee instead of sugar or flavored syrup, apple slices with peanut butter instead of a packaged snack, and sparkling water with orange slices or unsweetened tea instead of soda.

Even then, you don’t have to eliminate treats completely—in fact, McLean discourages that. “The emphasis should be on building a nutrient-dense foundation rather than eliminating individual foods,” she says.

Source link

Originally published by prevention.com. Syndicated material does not necessarily reflect the views of Glamour Canada.

More Lifestyle

More Than 2 Weekly Servings of These Foods Could Raise Breast Cancer Risk by 28%, Scientists Say - L'Officiel Lifestyle